Psychologists Sydney / Associated Counsellors Blog / Stonewalling in Relationships – Unveiling the Damage

Stonewalling in Relationships – Unveiling the Damage

Stonewalling in Relationships

Have you ever felt invalidated and frustrated in your conversations with your partner? If so, stonewalling may be the culprit. In this article, we delve into the detrimental impact of stonewalling, a communication pattern where one person shuts down dialogue and refuses to engage.

Discover why it poses a serious threat to relationships, learn to identify stonewalling behaviours, and explore effective strategies to foster open and healthy communication. Whether you’re directly involved or seeking a better understanding, this essential topic is worth exploring.

What is Stonewalling?

Stonewalling is a destructive communication pattern where one person avoids discussing issues or conflicts by becoming unresponsive or evasive. By refusing to engage, giving the silent treatment, or dismissing concerns, stonewalling may provide a temporary shield against overwhelming emotions. However, it inflicts frustration, disrespect, and hurt on the other person, creating disconnection and resentment in relationships. To foster healthier connections, it’s crucial to recognize stonewalling behaviours and prioritise open, honest communication to address conflicts and enhance relationships.

Examples of Stonewalling Behaviour

Recognizing stonewalling behaviours can be challenging, as they may appear as disinterest or indifference. However, certain telltale signs can help identify when someone is stonewalling:

– Silence or lack of response: Refusal to engage in conversation or resorting to the silent treatment.
– Avoidance: Changing the subject or diverting attention away from the issue at hand.
– Physical withdrawal: Physically removing oneself from the conversation or situation.
– Defensiveness: Becoming defensive and denying responsibility or wrongdoing.
– Minimal responses: Providing short, non-committal replies that hinder meaningful conversation.
– Dismissive language: Using phrases like “whatever” or “I don’t care” to dismiss and shut down the conversation.

By understanding these behaviours, individuals can gain insights into stonewalling tendencies and work towards fostering open and productive communication in their relationships.

Real-Life Scenarios of Stonewalling: Unveiling Silent Communication Breakdowns

Stonewalling can manifest in various real-life scenarios, such as:

1. Relationship Dispute: During an argument about finances, one partner feels unheard and responds by giving their partner the silent treatment, refusing to engage further.
2. Workplace Discussion: In a project meeting, a coworker consistently changes the subject whenever a challenging topic arises, attempting to evade conflict and maintain comfort.
3. Parent-Child Interaction: A parent addresses their teenager’s behaviour, but the child becomes defensive, shirking responsibility and shutting down the conversation completely.
4. Friendship Strain: Upset by their friend’s actions, an individual avoids direct expression of their feelings and instead withdraws from the friendship, becoming less available and communicative.
5. Therapeutic Session: Overwhelmed by emotions, a client in therapy emotionally shuts down, ceasing to respond to the therapist’s inquiries and retreating inward.

These examples illustrate that stonewalling can occur in any conversation, not solely during heated debates. Recognizing these scenarios helps shed light on the impact of silent communication breakdowns and the importance of fostering open, constructive dialogue.

Distinguishing Stonewalling from Other Behaviours

It’s vital to differentiate stonewalling from similar behaviours in order to understand its impact and address it effectively. Stonewalling, gaslighting, fighting, and claiming victim status all hinder communication and create emotional distance in relationships.

Although these behaviours may share some similarities, they possess distinct differences that aid in identification and constructive resolution.

Stonewalling and the silent treatment both involve a lack of communication and engagement, which can cause feelings of rejection and hurt. However, the silent treatment often emerges as a temporary response to a specific situation, while stonewalling tends to be a longer-lasting behavioural pattern. Additionally, the silent treatment may not always be intentional, while stonewalling usually entails a deliberate avoidance of communication.

Young man feeling sad after arguing with his girlfriend on sofa at home.

Gaslighting encompasses manipulating someone’s perception of reality to induce self-doubt or confusion, eroding trust and emotional security. While stonewalling can create emotional distance, it doesn’t typically involve a calculated manipulation of the other person’s reality.

Fighting entails engaging in heated arguments or conflicts, often with the aim of “winning” or asserting dominance. This can generate tension and emotional distance as both individuals may feel unheard or misunderstood. While stonewalling entails a lack of communication, it doesn’t involve the same aggressive confrontational nature as fighting.

Lastly, claiming victim status involves using personal struggles or difficulties to seek sympathy or evade responsibility. This can breed resentment and frustration in the other person, who may feel their concerns are dismissed or minimized. While stonewalling may impede the expression of one’s needs and emotions, it doesn’t involve exploiting one’s experiences or emotions to manipulate the conversation.

The Devastating Impact of Stonewalling: Undermining Relationships

Stonewalling inflicts severe damage on communication, trust, and emotional intimacy within relationships. Far from a mere lack of engagement, this behaviour carries profound consequences for individuals and couples alike. Beyond the immediate communication barriers, stonewalling triggers emotional turmoil, trust issues, intimacy challenges, and enduring impacts that corrode relationships over time.

Emotional Consequences

When subjected to stonewalling, individuals often experience a sense of being unheard, dismissed, and undervalued. This engenders anger, frustration, and resentment, resulting in a growing divide between partners. Feeling ignored and misunderstood hampers open and honest communication, making it harder for the recipient to believe that conflicts will be resolved or their perspective understood. This disappointment, bitterness, and resentment, left unaddressed, erodes the relationship and erodes trust.

Loneliness represents another emotional consequence of stonewalling. Though physically present, stonewallers remain emotionally distant, fostering disconnection and isolation that hinder the establishment of meaningful connections. When an individual fails to establish a profound emotional bond with their partner, feelings of loneliness and desolation ensue. Over time, these emotions can escalate into hopelessness, helplessness, and even depression. As communication falters, the future appears uncertain, taking a toll on individuals’ mental well-being.

Emotional Man sitting on Couch

Trust and Intimacy

Trust and intimacy are vital for healthy relationships, but stonewalling poses significant obstacles in their development. When one partner engages in stonewalling, an invisible barrier impedes meaningful conversations and constructive conflict resolution. This lack of communication fosters misunderstandings and resentment and erodes trust. Over time, the connection between partners weakens, hindering the cultivation of intimacy and understanding.

Long-Term Impact on Relationships

In the long run, stonewalling can devastate relationships. If it becomes a regular occurrence, lingering hurt and anger can hinder the resolution of differences and hinder the restoration of a strong connection. Without effective communication, couples may find themselves unable to progress, leading to an irreparable divide that may ultimately result in a breakup.

Dealing with Stonewalling in a Relationship

Addressing stonewalling in a relationship can be challenging, especially if both parties engage in this destructive behaviour or if one party adamantly refuses to change. Recognizing stonewalling’s detrimental effects on communication, trust, and emotional intimacy is crucial. Here are some strategies to cope with stonewalling:

Take a break: If both parties are stonewalling, stepping back from the conversation or argument can be necessary to cool off. This prevents escalation and allows time for reflection on emotions and needs.

Practice active listening: When one person is stonewalling, the other should practice active listening and show empathy. Creating a safe, non-judgmental space encourages the stonewalling individual to express their thoughts and feelings.

Establish boundaries: If one party persists in stonewalling, setting clear boundaries and communicating expectations for communication and emotional safety becomes essential. This promotes healthy communication patterns and prevents long-term stonewalling.

Seek professional help: In some cases, seeking professional assistance may be necessary to address stonewalling and underlying relationship issues. A qualified therapist can provide guidance and tools for navigating difficult conversations or arguments in a healthy manner.

The Role of Counselling in Overcoming Stonewalling

Overcoming stonewalling in a relationship can be a challenging journey, particularly if it has become a persistent pattern of behaviour. Counselling provides a valuable resource for couples struggling to communicate effectively or resolve conflicts. A qualified therapist can assist couples in identifying underlying issues contributing to stonewalling and offer support to address them in a healthy manner. This may involve exploring past traumas or experiences that impact the ability to engage in constructive communication.

Women in Counselling

The benefits of therapy in strengthening relationships include:

– Improved communication: Counselling equips couples with tools to communicate thoughts and feelings effectively, fostering open dialogue and mutual understanding.

– Increased trust and emotional intimacy: With the guidance of a therapist, couples can navigate difficult conversations or arguments, rebuilding trust and creating a safe space for open expression.

– Enhanced understanding of needs: Through counselling, couples gain insight into each other’s perspectives, fostering a deeper understanding of each other’s needs and desires within the relationship.

– Deeper connection: By addressing underlying issues contributing to stonewalling or conflict, couples can work towards a stronger bond and a more meaningful connection.

In summary, counselling serves as a valuable resource in overcoming stonewalling and strengthening relationships.


Stonewalling is a common issue in relationships, but it’s not one that has to remain unresolved. By making an effort to understand why it occurs and taking positive steps towards rebuilding trust and intimacy with your partner, you can work together to create a healthier and more fulfilling relationship. With the right resources and strategies, you can ensure that stonewalling doesn’t become a long-term problem in your relationship.

Stonewalling FAQS

  • How can I identify if my partner is stonewalling me?

    To identify if your partner is stonewalling you, pay attention to their response during conversations. Are they calm and collected or defensive in their replies? If they consistently avoid the conversation topic or confrontational situations, it may be a sign of stonewalling. Also, observe their communication frequency—do they typically respond promptly and directly, or do they make excuses to avoid answering? Non-verbal cues such as lack of eye contact, facial expressions, and closed-off posture may indicate that your partner is not fully present for the discussion. While these warning signs don't necessarily indicate a problem, coupled with unresponsiveness, they can suggest a potential issue between partners.

  • Are there any specific triggers that lead to stonewalling behaviour in relationships?

    There isn't a single cause of stonewalling, but some common triggers include feeling overwhelmed or powerless in a particular situation. Past traumas or difficult experiences can also make it challenging to open up and engage in meaningful conversations with your partner.

  • Can stonewalling be unintentional, or is it always a deliberate act?

    Stonewalling is often seen as an intentional act of ignoring or blocking communication to cause psychological, emotional, or even physical harm. However, it is possible for someone to stonewall unintentionally. In moments of high stress, individuals may struggle to react in a healthy, communicative manner and instinctively withdraw into silence and avoidance. This inadvertent stonewalling is a challenge many couples face when disagreements become heated and minds shut down, hindering meaningful conversations. It's important to remember that both deliberate and unintentional stonewalling can have detrimental effects on relationships, emphasising the need for non-judgemental communication when discussions become difficult.

  • How can I effectively express my feelings to my partner if I'm the one being stonewalled?

    Expressing your feelings can be challenging when you are being stonewalled, but it's important to remember that open and honest communication is essential for a healthy relationship. If possible, remain patient and understanding when your partner is unresponsive. Ask them about their feelings and reassure them that you still care about them and the relationship. If you feel overwhelmed, take some time for yourself and practice self-care.

  • What are some strategies for preventing stonewalling from occurring in the first place?

    Preventing stonewalling requires a focus on communication. Learning to discuss emotions in a non-confrontational manner can be immensely helpful, as can developing active listening skills and empathy. Maintaining respect for one another by avoiding name-calling or threats can also prevent conversations from escalating. Ask questions that show respect for your partner's opinions and perspectives, demonstrating a genuine effort to understand rather than challenge or dismiss their ideas. Regularly setting aside time for meaningful dialogue can also foster familiarity, comfort, and trust, making both partners more likely to choose communication over stonewalling as a means of resolution.

  • Can stonewalling ever be a healthy coping mechanism in certain situations?

    While stonewalling is generally considered an unhealthy coping mechanism—such as withdrawing for extended periods, disengaging from conversations, or avoiding uncomfortable topics—it may not apply to every scenario. In certain situations, allowing yourself space and time to gather your thoughts and feelings before discussing the underlying issue is essential for self-care. Communicating to your partner or those involved that you need some space is helpful, but it's important to be mindful of the intensity of your emotions during and after stonewalling. If you feel yourself withdrawing too deeply, it's crucial to ground yourself and re-engage with reality.

  • How can I encourage my partner to engage in open communication if they're prone to stonewalling?

    The first step in encouraging open communication with your partner is to explain why it's important. Explain that stonewalling can be damaging for your relationship and that it can make you both feel disconnected. Show them that you respect their boundaries and that it's okay to tell them if they're uncomfortable sharing certain information. Try to create an atmosphere of calmness and acceptance. Ensure that your body language conveys understanding, maintain gentle eye contact, and offer small gestures like a hug or touching their arm - such physical closeness will help them relax. Also, let them know that they don't need to fear criticism or judgment from you; instead, focus on listening when they communicate openly.

  • What are the long-term consequences of not addressing stonewalling in a relationship?

    When stonewalling isn't addressed within a relationship, the long-term effects can be damaging. Unchecked, stonewalling will lead to feelings of extreme frustration and loneliness on both sides as communication grinds to a halt. This lack of communication means issues can't be dealt with promptly, meaning problems accumulate until both parties eventually feel overwhelmed and unhappy in their relationship. Over time, stonewalling in a relationship takes a toll on a couple's trust, reducing their willingness to connect or make themselves vulnerable to one another.

  • Are there any self-help resources or books that can help me understand and overcome stonewalling in my relationship?

    Stonewalling can put a significant strain on relationships, but it is possible to understand and overcome it. Fortunately, some self-help resources are available that can help individuals in this situation take positive steps forward. I would suggest starting with books such as "Getting the Love You Want" by Harville Hendrix or "Love Sense" by Sue Johnson. Both of these offer insights into relationships and provide guidance on how to build healthier foundations for communication within the partnership. It is also worth exploring articles from reputable websites or seeking therapeutic help from relationship counsellors or therapists specializing in couples' issues. All of these strategies can provide valuable advice for understanding and overcoming stonewalling in any relationship.

  • How can I rebuild trust and intimacy with my partner after a period of stonewalling?

    Rebuilding trust and intimacy after a period of stonewalling can feel like an intimidating task. It's important, however, to understand that it is possible! After coming together with your partner and setting aside some time to talk things through, the process of rebuilding can begin. Creating a safe space for open communication by actively listening and having compassion for each other's feelings goes a long way in building trust between you both. Additionally, showing your partner that you support them, even during difficult conversations, sends the message that their thoughts and feelings are valued. This, combined with respecting each other's boundaries and engaging in joint activities that bring joy to the relationship, should help rebuild trust and create a more secure connection within the relationship.

Our Services

We offer a variety of services dealing with wellbeing and mental health. Select from one of the options below for further details.
(02) 8205 0566
Mon-Fri: 9:00am - 6:00pm     Sat: 9:00am - 1:00pm
Booking Request
We'll be in touch the same business day with some great options.

    Make a booking form loader


    We have received your enquiry.

    We will call you today to discuss your enquiry. normally within 2 hours.

    We offer each caller a personalised service to help you to make an informed choice about counselling. Part of our service is to take the time to answer your important questions and to help you decide on the practitioner who is best suited to your needs.

    On busier days there may be a delay. Please wait as we will call you and intend to offer you our full attention and assistance within 24 hours.

    With ‘Associated Counsellors’ you are in good hands assured that your therapist is professionally registered and bound by a code of professional ethics and conduct.